Week 18 Analyst Breakdown

Key insights from NFL prediction shows

Sources:NFL Daily (Rosenthal/Freeland)NFL PredictionsPack A Day (Grossi)

Analyst Playoff Picks

Who experts are picking for the Super Bowl

Consensus Pick
Chiefs
2 of 4 analysts
Chiefs
Super Bowl Picks
ChiefsChiefs(2)
BillsBills(1)
LionsLions(1)
By Analyst
Colin Cowherd
FS1
ChiefsvsLions=
Chiefs
Pete Prisco
CBS
BillsvsEagles=
Bills
Tom Brady
FOX
ChiefsvsEagles=
Chiefs
Kyle Long
CBS
RavensvsLions=
Lions
Dark Horse Picks
49ers (Colin Cowherd)Vikings (Pete Prisco)Bears (Kyle Long)

Key Takeaways

1

Broncos unanimous pick for #1 seed clincher

All analysts picking Denver to dominate a Chargers team resting Justin Herbert. Trey Lance starting for LA. Broncos defense hunting team sack record with incentives on the line.

"This could be a three-hour celebration. Sean Payton coming off wonky weeks wants to get back on track."Greg Rosenthal
2

Vikings defense playing historic football

Minnesota's defense hasn't allowed a passing touchdown in 8 weeks. Brian Flores' unit is the best in the league right now. Packers expected to rest starters with Clayton Tune likely starting.

"I've never been a part of a better performance than this."Harrison Smith
3

Bills emotional finale at Orchard Park

Last regular season game ever at the old stadium before moving to new facility. Bills fighting for the coveted 5 seed. Expect emotional plays and a fired-up crowd against a deflated Jets team.

"Maybe Dion Dawkins scores a touchdown for goodness sakes. Something that means something to them."Cynthia Freeland

BOLD TAKE:Chiefs should TANK to hurt Raiders draft position

With Mahomes out and KC eliminated, one analyst suggests the Chiefs losing would cost the Raiders the #1 overall pick. KC playing third-string QB makes upset possible.

"If I'm Kansas City, I'm doing everything in my power to lose this game to screw Las Vegas out of being the number one pick."NFL Predictions
5

AFC South chaos: Jags and Texans both rolling

Jacksonville fighting for #1 seed with longest active momentum. Houston owns NFL's longest win streak. Both could meet in playoffs - analysts unanimous both teams cover big spreads.

"The Jaguars are a freaking tough team. Trevor Lawrence at this high level, they can beat anybody."NFL Predictions

Picks Summary

GameRosenthalFreelandPredictionsGrossi
CAR @ TB
Panthers
Panthers
Panthers
Panthers
SEA @ SF
Seahawks
Seahawks
Seahawks
Seahawks
GB @ MIN
Vikings
Vikings
Vikings
Packers
DET @ CHI
Bears
Bears
Bears
Bears
LAC @ DEN
Broncos
Broncos
Broncos
Broncos
NYJ @ BUF
Bills
Bills
Bills
Bills
TEN @ JAX
Jaguars
Jaguars
Jaguars
Jaguars
IND @ HOU
Texans
Texans
Texans
Texans
BAL @ PIT
Ravens
Ravens
Ravens
Ravens
NO @ ATL
Falcons
Falcons
Saints
Falcons
ARI @ LAR
Rams
Rams
Rams
Rams
KC @ LV
Chiefs
Chiefs
Raiders
Chiefs
Unanimous picks: TB, SF, CHI, DEN, BUF, JAX, HOU, PIT, LAR

Insights extracted from NFL analyst prediction videos

Last updated: Tuesday, Jan 13, 2026

Members Get AI Chat Access